Skip to main content
Tourism PEI
Oysters, close up, Fall Flavours, Savour Victoria

Oyster Preparation

Oyster Preparation

Published November 16, 2022 | Tourism PEI
Categories: Culinary

Long recognized as one of the world's finest oysters, Malpeques from Prince Edward Island have an unequaled taste, superior appearance and excellent keeping quality. Oysters are versatile. In the shell, they can be baked, steamed, grilled or used in specialty dishes such as Oysters Pommary or Florentine. Shucked oysters are excellent deep-fried, sautéed, grilled, in chowders, soups, stews, pies, casseroles, stuffings, dressings, or as an appetizer or main course. The Malpeque is excellent on the half shell, served with nothing but its own liquor. Its clarity and purity of flavour make it the connoisseur's choice.

Oysters per serving

Appetizers: 6 oysters in the shell per serving Meal: 1 litre (1 quart) shucked oysters serves 6

Buying

Purchase from a supplier who has a good turnover and keeps oysters chilled at all times. Live oysters should have tightly closed, undamaged shells or, if gaping slightly, should close when tapped. Shucked oysters should have good color, a fresh smell and be packaged in clear, not cloudy, oyster liquor. The odour inside should be pleasant.

Storing

Store in a cold environment. Live oysters should be refrigerated (flat side of the shell up) for up to 3 weeks at a temperature of 5 degrees Celsius (40 degrees F). Oysters prefer airy packaging; do not store in closed containers or plastic bags. Do not wash shells until ready to use. Shucked oysters can be refrigerated for up to 1 week or frozen for 2 to 3 months.

Freezing

Do not freeze in the shell. To freeze, shuck and cover with their own strained liquor. Leave 1/2 cm of air space, seal the container and freeze at -18 degrees C (0 degrees F). Keep frozen until ready to eat, do not refreeze.

Preparation

Brush under running water just prior to use. Do not leave in water. Unless steaming in the shell, the first step in preparation is shucking or opening the oyster to access the meat.

Shucking

Protect your hand by wearing a heavy-duty rubber glove or folded kitchen towel. Hold the oyster in the palm of your hand, or hold it tightly against a hard surface with the cup or deep side down. Keep the bottom shell level to prevent spilling liquor. Locate the hinge and insert a knife between the shells by gently working it back and forth. When the knife is well in, twist it back and forth to open. Slide the knife across the top of the shell to cut the muscle and run under the body of the oyster. Spoon meats into a glass container. Strain juices through a sieve to remove any pieces of shell; pour over oysters. Cover and refrigerate until ready to use. For presentation in the shell, rinse the shells, setting aside the best shaped (with no chips) for serving. You can also place cleaned oysters in a microwave, flat side up, cook for 10-20 seconds on medium. Shuck. Preheat oven to 150 degrees C (300 degrees F). Place oysters, flat side up, in oven towards the bottom for 30-60 seconds.

On-The-Half Shell

This traditional presentation is simpler if you shuck oysters ahead of time. Place reserved half shells in a bed of crushed ice to hold them securely and keep them chilled. To serve, spoon oyster meats back into reserved shells and divide liquor between them. Malpeques have a wonderful taste when served "as is" or offer just a squeeze of lemon, a drop of hot sauce, horseradish, salt and pepper, sauces or salsas to taste.

Grades: Know What You Buy

Oysters are sold in several grades and sizes according to regulations set down by the Canadian Department of Fisheries and Oceans. These grades, mainly determined by the size and shape of the individual oyster shell, are a good mirror of the content.

1. Fancy or Choice
Top-grade oysters, with the best-looking shells, ideal for serving on the half shell. These oysters tend towards a rounded shell, with a deeply cupped bottom shell ensuring a full-plump oyster.

2. Standard
Tending towards a longer, or more irregular shell shape, these have a distinctive "cup" on the bottom shell, but not as deep as a Fancy or Choice. While an excellent choice for serving on the half shell, these oysters are also excellent for presentations that are cooked or served with sauces or garnishes. Good value with the typical Malpeque taste.

3. Commercial
Uneven shells, flatter than above. Often sold shucked, they are ideal for use where the shell is not part of the presentation. Packed in their own juices, or liquor, they retain a natural fresh flavour. Usually a very good buy for oyster meat as you'll find the same taste and high quality as other grades.

To Eat

Pick up the shell, taking care not to spill the oyster liquor. Bring the broad end to your lips, tip the shell and drink the juices. Tilt your head back and let the oyster slide in. Delicious!!

More Blogs

Published May 27, 2022

It's Patio Season

As summer approaches, Prince Edward Island abounds with options for dining outdoors. Choose to sip cocktails on a downtown rooftop, sail to a seaside patio or beachcomb for sea glass mere steps from your table.
Published May 2, 2022

Come for Tea

Treat yourself to afternoon tea at one of the many tea rooms and dining rooms on Canada's Food Island – it’s the quintessential Anne experience.
Published February 8, 2022

Lobster Season is Upon Us!

Lobster season is in full swing and Islanders and visitors alike are excited for their first taste.