There are three options that I can suggest- all a little different experience but give great value!
First off, New Glasgow Lobster Suppers located in New Glasgow has been in business for 60 years and has the traditional lobster supper experience locked - all you can eat mussels, chowder, salads, the rolls, along with the lobster (size of your choice) and pie for dessert including their mile high lemon meringue pie! Also lots of other choices for the landlover in your group!
Next - Water Prince Corner Shop in Downtown Charlottetown also does a bang up job - lobster of your choice, potato salad and roll!
Lastly- Clamdiggers in Cardigan, PE does their version of the traditional lobster supper - all homemade and cooked perfectly!
Hope that helps! Enjoy our Lobster!!
Chef Jeff McCourt